Category Archives: Sangley Point, Cavite

Sangley Closes, Marine Officer Killed

U.S. Naval Station Sangley Point
Republic of the Philippines (1948-1971)


A School Opens At Sangley

  The story of the dependent school at Sangley Point begins after the return of the U.S. Navy to the Philippines, and to Sangley, in 1945. In anticipation of the possible allied invasion of the Japanese mainland, an 8000 foot runway was constructed, along with the associated air operations and maintenance facilities. The invasion never took place, but Sangley’s importance as a support facility for the Seventh Fleet continued to grow. So did its complement of Navy, Marine, Coast Guard, and civilian personnel.
[Kindergarten]
  As the number military personnel at Sangley grew, so did the need to provide accommodations and facilities for the dependents that would ultimately accompany them. Not the least of these facilities, of course, would be a school. So, a group of Quonset huts was designated, and in August of 1948 the first dependent’s school was opened at Sangley Point!  At first, the school was comprised of grades 1-7 and only 65 students. But, as the number of dependents increased the school began to grow, eventually adding a kindergarten and the 8th, 9th, and 10th grades. Ultimately, in 1963, the Bureau of the Navy added 11th and 12th grades.

[Grade 4]

   The school was comprised of a series of Quonset huts linked together with a central corridor. The original buildings were constructed on concrete piers with wooden floors, but the newer ones on the eastern end were built on concrete slabs. All the buildings, however, were metal Quonset huts. The entire school grounds was enclosed by a fence made primarily of Marston matting, an interlocking, metal construction material used to construct emergency or temporary landing strips!

It Gets A Name

  And, yet, as the school grew it remained nameless for more than ten years! Then, in 1959 a contest was held among the students to name their own school! The prize of a U.S. Savings Bond went to Jackie Newell(’56-’59) for choosing a name which commemorated the American naval hero of the Revolutionary War, John Paul Jones.[1967 Graduation]  In 1967, JPJ came under the supervision of the Air Force and was incorporated into the District II, Pacific Area, DODDS. In March of the next year, it was accredited by the North Central Association of Colleges and Secondary Schools. By now, there were 650 students at JPJ from kindergarten to the 12th grade; ten times the number that was first enrolled in 1948! By 1970, that number would swell to 690. Plans were in the works for the construction of a new school when official word came on December 10,1970, that Naval Station Sangley Point was to terminate operations as a U.S. facility.

 Sangley Closes

  Hectic and chaotic days followed that fateful announcement. Things would never be the same at Sangley. Everyone began to pack up and ship everything to the States or to other military facilities. Robberies and burglaries became commonplace as criminal elements attempted to get what they could before it was all gone. A Marine officer on his way home from Vietnam was killed when a robbery attempt at the American Express office ended in gunfire. Students and teachers at JPJ, only a block away, had to remain in the classrooms until the incident was over.

  Finally, on June 30, 1971, after almost 23 years of service, John Paul Jones School was officially closed. The very next day Naval Station Sangley Point changed status from active to inactive. What followed was sixty days of frantic activity as everything that could be stripped out, disconnected, or dismantled was shipped out. Amidst all of this chaos, some shipments were lost or stolen. Lost or destroyed, also, were the JPJ school records. As a result, many graduating seniors had difficulty entering colleges and universities.

  Then, on September 1,1971, Sangley Point was officially turned over to the Philippine government.

http://homepage.mac.com/lstiegelmar1/jpj.html

Republic of the Philippines
SUPREME COURT
Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. L-53926-29 November 13, 1989

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee,
vs.
MANUEL MATEO, JR., ESMERALDO CRUZ, EMMANUEL CAGANAP, GENER FILOTEO, MANUEL MENDOZA, ROLANDO REYES, DANNY TOSCO, RENATO MENDOZA, MELANIO MENDOZA, ROBERTO MARTINEZ, ENRIQUE CONCEPCION, CHARLES “DOE”, GEORGE “DOE”, RICHARD “DOE”, BENJAMIN “DOE”, FRANK “DOE”, JOSEPH “DOE”, and ROBERT “DOE”, defendants, ENRIQUE CONCEPCION, defendant-appellant.

The Office of the solicitor General for plaintiff-appellee.

Carlos Ambrosio and Mario P. Gomez for defendant-appelant.

 

PADILLA, J.:

For having allegedly robbed the American Express Bank Branch located inside the United States Naval Base in Sangley Point, Cavite City and killed a U.S. marine officer on the occasion thereof, Manuel Mateo, Jr., Esmeraldo Cruz, Roberto Martinez @ Ruben Martinez, and Enrique Concepcion, members of the Cavite City police department, and Emmanuel Caganap, Gener Filoteo, Manuel Mendoza, Rolando Reyes, Danny Tosco, Renato Mendoza, Melanio Mendoza, and seven (7) persons whose Identities have remained unknown, were charged before the Circuit Criminal Court of Pasig, Rizal, with the crime of Robbery in Band with Homicide, and three (3) separate crimes of Robbery in Band, docketed therein as CCC-VII-843-Cavite City to CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, inclusive, committed as follows:

1. CCC-VII-843-Cavite City:

That on or about the 4th day of June, 1971, in Cavite City, Philippines and within the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court, the above-named accused, conspiring and confederating and helping one another, and with intent of gain and against the will of the owner thereof, armed with firearms, by means of force, violence, and intimidation did, then and there wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously rob, take and carry away from the American Express Bank Branch, a private firm duly represented by Antonio Laforteza, resident special agent, of the amount of $41,120.79 and P96,532.38, to the damage and prejudice of the latter in the aforesaid amount of $41,120.79 and P96,532.38; that as a consequence of an encounter during said Robbery in Band, the person of First Lt. James Plumpowski, USMC, who at that time responded to the alarm flashed by the bank personnel, sustained serious wounds on the vital parts of his body which caused his death.

The aggravating circumstances attendant thereto are the following:

1. Use of Motor Vehicle;

2. Taking advantage of superior strength;

3. Committed in band, all being armed;

4. Committed with the aid of persons who insure or afford impunity;

5. Committed with evident premeditation; and

6. That craft, fraud, or disguise was employed. 1

1. CCC-VII-844-Cavite City:

That on or about the 4th day of June 1971, in Cavite City, Philippines and within the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court, the above-named accused, conspiring and confederating and helping one another, with intent of gain and against the will of the owner thereof, armed with firearms, by means of force, violence and intimidation, did then and there wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously rob, take and carry I away from Antonio Araquel, the following articles, to wit:

Man’s wrist watch “Wiseman” valued at P50.00

Shoes valued at 21.00

Cash money in the amount of 15.00

Gate pass (unestimated amount) P86.00

to the damage and prejudice of the latter in the aforementioned amount of P86.00.

The aggravating circumstances attendant thereto are the following:

1. Use of motor vehicle;

2. Taking advantage of superior strength;

3. Committed in band, all being armed;

4. Committed with the aid of persons who insure or afford impunity;

5. That craft, fraud or disguise was employed. 2

3. CCC-VII-845-Cavite City:

That on or about the 4th day of June 1971, in Noveleta, Province of Cavite, Philippines and within the jurisdiction of its Honorable Court, the above-named accused conspiring and confederating and helping one another, with intent of gain and against the will of the owner thereof, armed with firearms, by means of force, violence and intimidation did, then and there wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously rob, take and carry away from the Aguinaldo Development Corporation ( Goody-Goody Bakery), a delivery truck with Plate No. 42-24xx, Manila 1971, valued at $1,500.00 which Aguinaldo Development Corporation is duly represented by Atty. Carlos, to the damage and prejudice of the latter corporation in the aforeamount of $1,500.00.

The aggravating circumstances attendant thereto are the following:

1. Use of Motor Vehicle;

2. Taking advantage of superior strength;

3. Committed in band, all being armed;

4. Committed with the aid of persons who insure or afford impunity;

5. Committed with evident premeditation; and

6. That craft, fraud or disguise was employed. 3

4. CCC-VII-846-Cavite City:

That on or about the 4th day of June, 1971, in Cavite City, Philippines and within the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court, the above-named accused conspiring and confederating and helping one another, with intent of gam and against the will of the owner thereof, armed with firearms, by means of force, violence and intimidation did, then and there wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously rob, take and carry away from Rodrigo Estrebillo his Driver’s License valued at P6.00, to the damage and prejudice of the afore-said driver in the amount of P6.00.

The aggravating circumstances attendant thereto are the following :

1. Use of Motor Vehicle;

2. Taking advantage of superior strength;

3. Committed in Band, all being armed

4. Committed with the aid of persons who insure or afford impunity; and

5. That craft, fraud or disguise was employed. 4

When arraigned, the accused entered pleas of NOT GUILTY, except for Emmanuel Caganap who pleaded GUILTY to the charges and was accordingly sentenced, in Crim. Case No. CCC-VIII-843- Cavite City, to suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua; to indemnify the heirs of the deceased Lt. James Plumpowski in the amount of P12,000.00; to pay the American Express Bank Branch, thru Antonio Laforteza, the amounts of $41,120.79 and P96,532.38; to pay the amount of P10,000.00 as moral damages and another P10,000.00 as exemplary damages, and to pay the costs; and in CCC-VII-844-Cavite City, CCC-VII-845-Cavite City and CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, to suffer the penalty of from two (2) years, four (4) months and one (1) day of prision correccional, as minimum, to four (4) years and two (2) months of prision correccional, as maximum, in each of the aforestated cases; and to indemnify the complainants Antonio Araquel in the amount of P86.00; the Aguinaldo Development Corporation, in the amount of $1,500.00; and Rodrigo Estrebillo, in the amount of P6.00; and to pay the costs. 5

The accused Rolando Reyes subsequently withdrew his plea of NOT GUILTY and pleaded GUILTY to the charges. He was consequently sentenced, in Crim. Case No. CCC-VII-843-Cavite City, to suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua; to indemnify the heirs of the deceased Lt. James Plumpowski in the amount of P12,000.00; to pay the American Express Bank Branch, thru Antonio Laforteza, the amounts of $41,120.79 and P96,532.38; to pay the amount of P10,000.00 as moral damages and another P10,000.00 as exemplary damages; and to pay the costs; and in Crim. Cases Nos. CCC-VII-844- Cavite City, CCC-VII-845-Cavite City and CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, to suffer the penalty of from two (2) years, four (4) months and one (1) day of prision correccional, as minimum, to four (4) years and two (2) months of prision correccional, as maximum, in each of the aforesaid cases; and to indemnify the complainants Antonio Araquel in the amount of P86.00, the Aguinaldo Development Corporation, in the amount of $1,500.00, and Rodrigo Estrebillo in the amount for P6.00; and to pay the costs. 6

On 5 November 1973, upon motion of the City Fiscal, the charges against the accused Manuel Mendoza were dismissed. 7

After a joint trial of the cases and an assessment of the evidence presented by the parties, judgment was rendered by the court a quo on 5 November 1979, as follows:

WHEREFORE, in Criminal Case No. CCC-VII-843-Cavite City, the Court finds the accused Manuel Mateo, Jr.; Esmeraldo Cruz, Gener Filoteo, Renato Mendoza, Melanio Mendoza, Roberto Martinez @ Ruben Martinez and Enrique Concepcion GUILTY beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Robbery in Band with Homicide, as defined in paragraph 1, Article 294 of the Revised Penal Code, as charged in the Amended Information; and the Court hereby sentences all of the said accused to suffer the penalty of RECLUSION PERPETUA, with accessory penalties prescribed by law; ordering them to indemnify jointly and severally the heirs of the offended party, Lt. James Plumpowski in the amount of Twelve Thousand Pesos (P12,000.00); ordering them to pay jointly and severally the American Express Bank Branch, thru Antonio Laforteza, the amount of Forty-one Thousand One Hundred Twenty Dollars and Seventy-nine Cents ($41,120.79), or its equivalent in Philippine Currency, and the amount of Ninety-six Thousand Five Hundred Thirty-two Pesos and Thirty-eight Centavos (P96,532.38); and to pay their proportionate share of the costs.

In Criminal Case No. CCC-VII-844-Cavite City, the Court finds the accused Manuel Mateo, Jr., Esmeraldo Cruz, Gener Filoteo Renato Mendoza, Melanio Mendoza, Roberto Martinez @ Ruben Martinez, and Enrique Concepcion GUILTY beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Robbery in Band, as defined in paragraph 5, Article 294 of the Revised Penal Code, as charged in the Amendment Information; and the Court hereby sentences all of the said accused to suffer imprisonment of FOUR (4) YEARS, TWO (2) MONTHS and ONE (1) DAY, as minimum, to SIX (6) YEARS, as maximum, with accessory penalties prescribed by law; ordering them to indemnify jointly and severally the offended party, Antonio Araquel, in the amount of Eighty-six Pesos (P86.00); and to pay their proportionate share of the costs.

In Criminal Case No. CCC-VII-845-Cavite City, the Court finds the accused Manuel Mateo, Jr., Esmeraldo Cruz, Gener Filoteo, Renato Mendoza, Melanio Mendoza, Roberto Martinez @ Ruben Martinez, and Enrique Concepcion GUILTY beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Robbery in Band, as defined in paragraph 5, Article 294 of the Revised Penal Code, as charged in the Amended Information; and the Court hereby sentences all of the said accused to suffer imprisonment of FOUR (4) YEARS, TWO (2) MONTHS, and ONE (1) DAY, as minimum, to SIX (6) YEARS, as maximum, with accessory penalties prescribed by law; and to pay their proportionate share of the costs.

In Criminal Case No. CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, the Court finds the accused Manuel Mateo, Jr., Esmeraldo Cruz, Gener Filoteo, Renato Mendoza, Melanio Mendoza, Roberto Martinez @ Ruben Martinez, and Enrique Concepcion GUILTY beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Robbery in Band, defined in paragraph 5, Article 294 of the Revized Penal Code. as charged in the Amended Information, and the Court hereby sentences all “he said accused to suffer imprisonment of FOUR YEARS, TWO 2) MONTHS and ONE DAY, asminimum, to SIX (6) YEARS, as maximum, with accessory penalties prescribed by law; ordering them to indemnify jointly and severally the offended party, Rodrigo Estrebillo, in the amount of Six Pesos (P6.00); and to pay their proportionate share of the costs.

In the service of the sentence, all of the said accused are entitled to Article 29 of the Revised Penal Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 6127.

As regards the accused Danilo Tosco @ Danny Tosco this Court finds the evidence against him insufficient to warrant his conviction beyond reasonable doubt for all the crimes charged in Criminal Cases Nos. CCC-VII-843, 844, 845 and 846-Cavite, and hereby ACQUITS said accused. 8

From this judgment, the accused Manuel Mateo, Jr., Esmeraldo Cruz, and Enrique Concepcion appealed. Manuel Mateo, Jr. and Esmeraldo Cruz, however, subsequently withdrew their appeals. 9

The incriminatory facts of these cases, as contained in the People’s Brief, are as follows:

At about 4:45 o’clock in the morning of June 4, 1971, Rodrigo Estrebillo was driving the Goody-Goody delivery truck of the Aguinaldo, Inc., coming from its bakery at V. Mapa, Manila to deliver bread at the then U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point, Cavite City. With Estrebillo in the truck was Antonio Araquel a helper. At approximately 7:00 o’clock of the same morning of June 4, 1971, while the Goody-Goody truck was travelling at the Lido Beach Resort and upon reaching a curve near Long Beach, a passenger jeep with armed men on board suddenly cut across the way of the Goody-Goody truck. Estrebillo immediately stopped the truck. Three armed men alighted from the jeep and one of them poked a gun at Estrebillo, shoved him to the side and took over the wheels of the Goody-Goody truck. The second armed man likewise poked a gun at Antonio Araquel and ordered him to alight from the truck and to go inside the passenger jeep. The third man blindfolded Estrebillo with an undershirt and sat in front of the truck sandwiching Estrebillo between him and the other armed man. Estrebillo Identified the armed man who poked a gun at him as Roberto or Ruben Marinez. Araquel Identified the man who pointed a gun at him and ordered him to go to the passenger jeep as Gener Filoteo. The man who took over the driver’s seat from Estrebillo was Identified as Emmanuel Caganap. Thereafter, the passenger jeep proceeded to Bay Court Hotel in Cavite City near the police checkpoint. Following the passenger jeep was the Goody- Goody truck driven by Emmanuel Caganap,

At the Bay Court Hotel, Estrebillo and Araquel were brought inside a room. Estebillos blindfold was removed. Martinez asked Araquel how to use the gate pass to enter Sangley Point and the latter informed Martinez that the receipt for the bread should be stamped by a doctor before actual delivery. Martinez took the gate pass and the receipt for the bread from Araquel as well as Estrebillo’s driver’s license. Araquel was stripped of his watch worth P50.00, shoes worth P20.00 and cash money of P15.00. Estrebillo and Araquel were warned by Martinez that they would be killed and be seen floating in the sea should they tell anyone what happened.

Aside from Martinez and Filoteo, who were Identified by Estrebillo and Araquel other armed men were Identified by Marilyn Tordecillas Orendain, wife of the Assistant Manager of the Bay Court Hotel, Gin Moe alias Lee. Mrs. Orendain was at the hotel at 6:00 o’clock in the morning of June 4, 1971. They saw Roberto Martinez and Enrique Concepcion arrive. She also Esmeraldo Cruz come in when Martinez asked for a drink. Concepcion sat in front of Mrs. Orendain a little away from the counter. At past seven o’clock of the same morning, she saw a passenger jeep arrive with armed men followed by a Goody-Goody truck. The jeep parked near the second house in the house compound, while the Goody-Goody truck went straight to the fourth house and then returned to the second house where the jeep was parked. Also among the group were Manuel Mateo, Jr., or June Mateo, the brothers Melanio and Renato Mendoza, a certain Doming, Didong, Lando and Eddie Mata.

It was at the Bay Court Hotel where Martinez spelled out the details of the plan to rob the American Express Bank inside Sangley Point. At about 10:00 a.m., after Martinez had acquired the necessary information as to how the entrance to the U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point could be effected, the Goody-Goody truck, driven by Emmanuel Caganap, left the Bay Court Hotel and proceeded to the base. Beside Caganap in front of the truck was Gener Filoteo. Inside the truck were Rolando Reyes. Renato and Melanio Mendoza, Doming and Didong. The rest of the group comprising Martinez, Mateo, Cruz, Concepcion and Eddie Mata rode in a jeep in going to Sangley Point.

xxx xxx xxx

Martinez also suave out last-minute instructions. He told the men in the Goody-Goody truck that his group composed of himself, Mateo, Concepcion Cruz, Eddie Mata and Lando and would be outside the base and would fire to confuse the Americans. Martinez further said that if there be any danger, hostages would have to be taken.

And so, at about ten o’clock in the morning of June 4, 1971, in furtherance of the conspiracy, with Caganap driving, with Filoteo beside him, and with Reyes, Melanio and Renato Mendoza, Doming and Didong inside the Goody-Goody truck, the group proceeded towards the American Express Bank inside Sangley Point. While still away from the bank, Gener Filoteo and Renato Mendoza alighted from the Goody-Goody truck and walked to the bank. On the pretext that they were looking for the Administration Building, they asked a U.S. Marine on guard posted at the bank where the Administration Building is located. However, the marine did not understand the question, is he did not answer. Filoteo and Renato Mendoza then asked a Filipino who was there at the moment, and the Filipino pointed to the Administration Building. Filoteo and Renato Mendoza proceeded to cross the street towards the Administration Building. At the moment, the Goody- Goody truck arrived. Immediately, Filoteo and Mendoza returned to the bank pointed their guns at the marine on guard, Para Guadalupe, handcuffed him at the railings of the stairs in front of the bank and took the marine’s shotgun and radio. Almost simultaneously, the armed men inside the Goody-Goody truck alighted and proceeded inside the bank. Filoteo and Renato Mendoza followed but not until after Filoteo had ordered two of the “cuadra” boys to stand guard outside the bank near the handcuffed marine, Para Guadalupe. The latter recognized from the picture, Exhibit “G-3″, the man wearing a cap, and Identified him as Gener Filoteo, as one of the two armed men who approached him, handcuffed him and took his shotgun and radio. According to him the two armed men standing outside the bank near the place where he was handcuffed. fired shots in the air to scare people.

Ismael Bob Pittman, a U.S. marine assigned at the U.S. Naval Base, Sangley Point, was inside the barracks when he heard the bank alarm. Responding to the alarm, Pittman and several other U.S. marines, among whom were Capt. Taylor, S/Sgt. Mc Daniel, Sgt. Greene, Cpl. Mitchell, Pfc. Thompson, boarded a marine truck and proceeded direction of the bank. There was an exchange of gunfire between the marines and the armed men in the bank. Pittman hid behind a tree, but could not return fire as he left his firearm in the marine vehicle. In the ensuing gunbattle Pittman and Para Guadalupe saw Lt. James Plumpowki fatally shot.

Inside the American Express Bank, the employees were performing their usual duties. Helena Parcero was secretary and assistant vault custodian. Nicanor Obtera was senior teller and senior custodian of the bank. Other employees were Lucila Santos. teller No. 5; Edgardo Moncal, teller No. 2; and Angelina Basto The Bank Manager, Robert Gilman, was in his office. When the four or five armed men entered the bank, one of them shouted, “Everybody, do not move; this is a hold-up,” and asked for the Manager. Nicanor Obtera pointed to the Bank Manager, who came out from his office. Upon orders from the armed men, Gilman told Obtera to open the vault. Obtera and Parcero then opened the vault, with two armed men behind them. After the two safes in the vault were opened, the armed man holding a sack ordered Obtera and Parcero to take the pesos from one safe and the dollars from the other safe and to place them in the sack.

During the shooting that ensued, the man armed with a rifle was hit in the head. The bleeding man sat near the grill door of the vault, took off his shirt and tied it around bis head. This man was Identified as Renato Mendoza. Another gunman was shot and who was later Identified as Emmanuel Caganap. One of the gunmen, known as Doming was killed.

Meanwhile, Daniel Luchyz, a U. S. navyman who was standing in front of the American Express Bank at the time the Goody-Goody truck passed, was ordered by the armed man carrying a rifle to go inside the bank, and there he was told by the man carrying .45 caliber pistol and with a gun slung across his shoulder, to carry the sack of money outside the bank. The other armed men took hostages with them, rushed out of the bark towards a parked marine truck, boarded the vehicle, sped towards the west gate and made their exit at the portion of the gate where the wire fence was cut two days before the incident. A group of armed men waited outside the fence for their companions and they all made their escape with the bank loot.

Almost at the same time that the bank heist was happening, another scene was transpiring at the main gate of the U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point, John L. Tori, Jr. a U.S. marine stationed at Sangley Point, was at the main gate of the base at about ten o’clock in the morning of June 4, 1971 with his wife Joselita Tori to shop at the base commissary. When he heard the alarm, he went back to the gate to close it. Tori heard four shots outside the gate and saw a woman running towards the gate. Tori also saw a man running towards Post No. 3 holding and firing a .45 caliber pistol. Tori Identified him as Manuel Mateo Jr., Tori also saw another armed man who fired his weapon. A jeep with motor still running was parked outside the fence of the base about a yard from the tower post. Tori Identified Esmeraldo Cruz as the one seated inside the jeep with another man with his back turned. After helping to safety a woman and a child inside the gate, Tori ran towards Post No. 3, where marine Elliot J. Grey was on guard duty, positioned at the tower located at the fence along the Street.

Elliot saw a jeep pass the tower three times and at the fourth time, the jeep pulled off in a corner and two men got out of the jeep, who started filing inside the base, one with .45 caliber pistol and the other with a Thompson sub-machine gun. As the two men “fired, they ran down the street behind the jeep which turned to the corner. Elliot then got out of the tower and ran to the main gate, met Tori and helped to move people recover. About two three minutes after the men fired from outside the base, Elliot heard firing from the direction of the American Express Bank. Elliot proceeded to the bank and had an argument with the wife of the Bank Manager, who wanted to go to the bank to see her husband, but Elliot brought her to safety inside a house. Elliot identified Mateo as the gunman who fired the .45 caliber pistol and Martinez as the man who fired the Thompson submachinegun.

Merle Dyer is a journalist of the U.S. Navy, Subic Naval Base. On June 4, 1971, he was assigned to the U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point as a photographer. Dyer had no actual knowledge that a robbery was being committed at the American Express Bank, but he had a feeling that something was happening from what he saw and heard. He loaded 20 films in his Nikkon 35mm camera, with 105 mm. lens. He positioned himself at the glass of the window in an office about 75 meters away from the scene. In kneeling position, Dyer took several pictures, using 19 of the 20 films in his camera. The films were processed by a technician and photograph officer at the base laboratory. Among the films were being processed, Dyer was outside the door of the laboratory. Among the films developed, the following are the significant ones:

Exhibit “C” depicts an American holding a gun crouched near a panel truck. In the background is the building housing the American Express Bank inside the U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point Exhibit “C-1-a” depicts an armed in prone position near a tree with a motorcycle nearby . Exhibit “C-2-a” shows an armed man emerging from the bank building which is a sequence to Exhibit “C- l”. Exhibit “C-3-a” shows a dead man near a tree, one of the armed robbers. Exhibit “C-4-a” shows the American hostage, Daniel Luchyz carrying the sack of money and behind him is the gunman later Identified as accused Gener Filoteo. This is a sequence to Exhibit “C”, Exhibit “C-5″ is blowup of Exhibit “C-4″ in which the marine hostage Daniel Luchyz and the up accused Gener Filoteo, Exhibit “G-5-b”, are depicted. Exhibit “C-6″ shows another gunman herding hostages, Exhibit “C-6-a”. Exhibit “C- 7″ shows accused Filoteo at the back of the American hostage Daniel Luchyz, Exhibit “C-7-b” with Goody-Goody truck, Exhibit “C-7-a”, clearly visible. Exhibits “C-8″, “C-9″ and “C-10″ depict accused Renato Mendozawith bandaged head at the back of the Manager of the American Express Bank. Exhibit “C-11″ clearly shows accused Gener Filoteo, Exhibit “C-11-c”, pointing a gun at the American hostage Daniel Luchyz Exhibit “C-11-b”, who was carrying the sack of money near the Goody-Goody truck, Exhibit “C-11-a”. Exhibits “C-12″ and “C-13″ show accused Renato Mendoza with bandaged head, holding a gun behind the Bank Manager with raised hands and the American hostage Daniel Luchyz, Exhibit “C-12-a-l”, Exhibit “C- 13-b-l”, carrying the sack of money near the Goody- Goody truck. Exhibit “C-1 4 clearly shows the accused Renato Mendoza, with bandaged head behind Bank Managers Rolando Reyes, Exhibit “C-14-1″, and Melanio Mendoza, Exhibit “G3″. Exhibits “C-15″ and “C-16″ show the persons being herded by a gunman in front of the bank.

Dr. William Hunter, Jr., a physician of the U.S. Naval Command Institution at San Miguel Zambales was working at the dispensary of the U.S. Naval Base at Sangley Point on June 4, 1971. At about 10:50 a.m. the body of the slain Lt. James Plumpowski was brought into the dispensary. Together with two other doctors, Dr. Hunter examined the body of Lt. Plumpowski found two large wounds on the left side of the chest (Exhibits “B-1-a” and “B-1-b”) and a small wound on the left arm (Exhibit “B-1-c”). The marine officer was dead on arrival at the dispensary (Exhibit “B”). Cause of death was external and internal hemorrhage due to gunshot wounds.

Meanwhile at the Bay Court Hotel where the armed group left Rodrigo Estrebillo and Antonio Araquel driver and helper of the Goody-Goody truck, respectively, it was about 2:30 oclock in the afternoon of June 4, 1971 that the two left the hotel. They went towards the police checkpoint in front thereof and boarded a Saulog bus to Manila. Stopping at Baclaran, Estrebillo and Araquel took the JD transit bound for Monumento, alighting at Mandaluyong and from there proceeded towards Quiapo dropping at the Aguinaldo, Inc. office at V. Mapa, Manila. After Estrebillo reported the incident, he was accompanied to the NBI office by Atty. Fernandez, lawyer of the Aguinaldo, Inc., and there Estrebillo narrated what happened to him and Antonio Araquel Atty. Rogelio M. Carlos, Assistant Chief Legal Counsel of the Aguinaldo, Inc., Identified the Goody-Goody truck as one of the properties of the Aguinaldo, Inc. (Exhibits “H” and “H-l”) valued at $1,500.00 (Exhibit “H-2″) Incidentally, the Goody-Goody truck was released to its owner on July 5, 1971 by the Cavite PC Command at Imus Cavite.

After the robbery, Antonio Laforteza, agent of the American Express Company, conducted an investigation on June 4, 1971, together with the company travelling auditor. The investigation revealed that the loss sustained by the American Express Bank as aresult of the armed robbery amounted to P96,532.38 and $41,120.79 (Exhibit “M”).

Immediately after the robbery of the American Express Bank, PC forces under Col. Daniel G. Lira, PC Cavite Provincial Commander, captured Emmanuel Caganap, one of the wounded gunmen, in a house in Cavite City. Interviewed by M/Sgt. Prospero B. Gapas of the Cavite PC Command, Caganap confessed and admitted his participation in the Sangley Point holdup and named as his companions, Ruben Martinez Enrique Concepcion, Manuel Mateo, Jr., Rolando Reyes, and Renato Mendoza. Caganap also stated in the interview which was reduced into writing by Sgt. Gapas (Exhibit “A”) that Ruben Martinez supplied them with three .45 caliber pistols, two carbines, and three M-16 armalites.

At about 5:30 p.m. of the same day, June 4, 1971, the military authorities under Col. Lira received information that Martinez, Concepcion and Mateo were at the residence of Fiscal Dante Filoteo at 535 Guzman Street, Caridad, Cavite City. The house was cordoned and guarded to prevent escape. At 6:00 p.m., Col. Lira met Fiscal Filoteo two or three blocks away from his house. Fiscal Filoteo was informed that the three suspects in the robbery (Martinez, Concepcion and Mateo) were in his house and that he should help facilitate their surrender, but Fiscal Filoteo refused. At about 8:00 p.m., Col. Lira met Mayor Dones of Cavite City, Governor Montano and Fiscal Filoteo at the Pagoda Restaurant. Montano and Dones joined in convincing Filoteo to help in the surrender of the three suspects. Again Filoteo declined and said he was afraid to go to his house because there might be shooting, Finally, at one o’clock in the morning of June 5, 1971 when Fiscal Filoteo learned that the Chief of the Philippine Constabulary would not countermand Col. Lira’s order, Fiscal Filoteo relented and accompanied by Police Chief Del Rosario of the Cavite City Police, Fiscal Filoteo went to his house. Thereafter, Fiscal Filoteo came out with Martinez, Mateo and Concepcion. Confiscated were an armalite from Concepcion (Exhibit “O-1″) and “a carbine from Martinez (Exhibit “O-2″). The three suspects were brought to Camp Crame immediately for investigation. However, only Martinez gave a statement (Exhibit “U”), while Mateo and Conception refused.

On September 30, 1971, elements of the PC-CIS arrested Rolando Reyes in barrio Pugad, Hagonoy, Bulacan. Taken to the CIS office at Camp Crame, Reyes was investigated by T/Sgt. Marcial Admana on October 1, 1971 in the presence of CIS Senior Agent Berlin Castillo and Investigating Agent Cesar Catibog. In an extra-judicial confession (Exhibit “P”), Rolando Reyes narrated in detail the circumstances surrounding the bank robbery in Sangley Point, Cavite City and he named his co-accused herein as participants in the said robbery.

On December 9, 1972, Gener Filoteo was arrested by CIS agents in his place of work in Cavite City. On December 11, 1972, he gave a statement to the CIS before Sgt. Jacinto Astrero which corroborated in substantial detail the confession of Rolando Reyes. Filoteo’s extrajudicial confession appears in Exhibit “Q”, “Q-l” to “Q-7″ and Identified himself, Rolando Reyes, Renato and Melanio Mendoza in the pictures (Exhibits “Q-8″ and “Q-9″).

On December 16, 1972, the brothers Renato and Melanio Mendoza, accompanied by their mother and former Vice-Mayor of Imus Francisco Herrera, went to see Gen. Cicero Campos at U.P. Village to surrender. As Gen. Campos was not at home, they were told by an aid to proceed to the CIS at Camp Crame. Before Sgt. Astrero Melanio Mendoza executed an extra-judicial confession (Exhibits “R”, “R-l” to “R-3″), describing in detail the armed robbery at the American Express Bank at Sangley Point on June 4, 1671. Melanio Mendoza corroborated in material points the confession of Rolando Reyes and Gener Filoteo. On the other hand, Renato Mendoza executed and signed a statement (Exhibits “S” and “S-l”) affirming the truth of his brother Melanio’s confession. 10

The appellant, Enrique Concepcion, denied having participated in the commission of the crimes charged and interposed the defense of alibi. The trial court summarized his evidence, as follows:

Accused Enrique Concepcion was a police sergeant of Cavite City on June 4, 1971, in-charge of the mobile patrol with tour of duty from 8:00 p.m. to 4:00 a.m.. According to Concepcion, he went home after his tour of duty was finished, took his snack, and was about to sleep when policeman Esmeraldo Cruz arrived at about past 5:00 a.m. Cruz told him that Vice-Mayor Eduardo de Guzman would like to talk to him about the suspected killer of the brother of the Vice-Mayor. Concepcion told Cruz that he would follow. Cruz rode in the mobile car, while, Concepcion took his jeep.

At Salem Restaurant Concepcion talked to Vice-Mayor De Guzman who told him to go to the check-point to prevent the escape of the killer of his brother. It was past 5:00 a.m. when Concepcion and Cruz left the restaurant. Cruz parked the mobile car at his house and rode with Concepcion in the latter’s service jeep to the check-point, arriving there at 6:00 a.m..

Cpl. Felix Tiongco was at the checkpoint, Tiongco asked Concepcion and Cruz why they came and he was told that Vice- Mayor De Guzman ordered them to be on the look-out for the killer of the Vice-Mayor’s brother, a certain Roberto Javitan. Pat Manuel Mateo, Jr., also arrived at the checkpoint. At about 9:30 a.m., Cpl. Tiongco received a call from the Vice-Mayor and he told him that Concepcion and Cruz may go home already. Tiongco relayed the message of the Vice-Mayor to Concepcion and Cruz.

At the same moment, a spare-parts dealer from Pasay City, Benigno Medina, arrived at the checkpoint in a jeep containing spare parts for a jeep that Concepcion was then assembling. Medina met Concepcion at the checkpoint and they went together in Medina’s jeep to Concepcion’s house at Makisig Street, San Antonio, Cavite City, to deliver the spare parts. After unloading the spare parts, while Concepcion and Medina were having snack, Concepcion’s wife arrived from the market at about 11:00 a.m. She told Concepcion that there was a robbery at Sangley Point. Immediately, Concepcion went to the police headquarters taking Medina’s jeep. He carried with him an armalite and a .38 Cal. revolver. Concepcion asked the Desk Officer Pfc. Virgilio Salazar (now dead) about the Sangley Point incident, and he was told by Salazar that he was a suspect with a shoot-to-kill order for him and that he better see the Police Chief Del Rosario.

Concepcion, went to Del Rosario’s residence and was waiting for more than an hour, when Fiscal Dante Filoteo arrived. Concepcion told Fiscal Filoteo that he was a suspect in the Sangley Point case and that there was a shoot-to-kill order for him by the PC. Filoteo told Concepcion that he would contact the PC Commander about it. Concepcion stayed until about 1:00 p.m. at the house of the Chief of Police, but he left when the Police Department called the Chiefs house that he could not come home. Concepcion then proceeded to Fiscal Filoteo’s house. At about 2:00 p.m., Mateo and Martinez arrived at the Fiscal’s house and told Concepcion that they too were suspects in the Sangley Point robbery; that they also went to the residence of Chief of Police, but did not see him that they were told that Concepcion went to the residence of Fiscal Filoteo; and that they followed to seek the aid of the Fiscal to surrender.

At past midnight of June 5, 1971, Fiscal Filoteo arrived at his house, which was then surrounded by soldiers. Concepcion recognized Fiscal Filoteo and told him to come in. Filoteo led the three-Concepcion, Martinez and Mateo-outside and surrendered them to Col. Lira, the Provincial Commander. According to Concepcion, a.38 caliber revolver was grabbed from his waist by a PC soldier. No receipt was issued to him for the revolver because according to him, there was a commotion when the PC Soldiers disarmed Fiscal Filoteo of his firearm. At past 1:00 a.m., Concepcion, Martinez and Mateo were brought to the CIS, Camp Crame, where they were investigated and charged with illegal Possession of firearms. However, they were acquitted of the offense (Exhibit “3-Concepcion”). 11

This appeal involves the determination of the question of whether or not the accused-appellant Enrique Concepcion conspired with his co-accused in the commission of the crimes charged. Counsel for the appellant contends that there is no iota of proof that the appellant actually participated in the commission of the offenses charged and/or in the furtherance of a conspiracy to rob the American Express Bank at the U.S. Naval Base in Sangley Point, Cavite.

The contention is devoid of merit. Conspiracy need not be proved by direct evidence. It need not be shown that the parties actually came together and agreed in express terms to enter into and pursue a common design. The assent of the minds may be and, from the secrecy of the crime, usually inferred from proof of facts and circumstances which, taken together, indicate that they are parts of some complete whole. If it is proved that two or more persons aimed by their acts, at the accomplishment of the same unlawful object, each doing a part so that their acts, though apparently independent, were in fact connected and cooperative, indicating a closeness of personal association and a concurrence of sentiment, a conspiracy may be inferred though no actual meeting among them to concert ways and means is proved. 12

In the instant cases, the accused Emmanuel Caganap, Rolando Reyes, Gener Filoteo, Melanio Mendoza and Renato Mendoza stated in their extra-judicial confessions given to PC investigators soon after their arrest, 13 that the appellant, Enrique Concepcion, was their companion in robbing the American Express Bank Branch in the U.S. Naval Base in Sangley Point on 4 June 1971. Rolando Reyes and Gener Filoteo also stated that the appellant was one of those who acted as “look-outs” outside the base and waited for them outside the hole they had previously made in the wire fence to facilitate their exit from the naval base. Melanio Mendoza and Gener Filoteo further stated that they saw the appellant inside the Bay Court Hotel talking to Ruben Martinez. These extra-judicial confessions were given when the presumption of law was in favor of spontaneity and voluntariness of a confession and it was incumbent upon the accused to destroy that presumption; 14 and yet, no evidence had been presented to overcome that presumption except the retracting testimonies of Gener Filoteo, Melanio Mendoza, and Renato Mendoza to the effect that they did not give the implicatory statements. However, the accused Emmanuel Caganap and Rolando Reyes, who both pleaded guilty, did not recant their statements. 15 Besides, the recitals therein reflect spontaneity and coherence and are replete with details that only the confessants could have known and supplied.

The appellant claims, however, that the said extra- judicial confessions of his co-accused should not be taken against him following the rule of res inter alios acta.

The cited rule is not absolute. In the case of People v. Ty Sui Wong16 the Court said:

Since People vs. Badilla, the rule which has been reiterated by this Court in various cases is that extrajudicial confessions, independently made without collusion, which are Identical with each other in their essential details and are corroborated by other evidence on record, are admissible as circumstantial evidence against the person implicated to show the probability of the latter’s actual participation in the commission of the crime.

Inasmuch as there is no proof of collusion among the declarants, their confessions should, therefore, be read together to form a complete picture of the commission of the crime and considered collectively as corroborative or confirmatory of the evidence apart from the confessions themselves.

There is no evidence of collusion and the extra-judicial confessions of appellant’s co-accused are corroborated by Marilyn Tordecillas Orendain, wife of the Assistant Manager of the Bay Court Hotel, who declared that she saw the appellant. Enrique Concepcion, at a little past 6:00 o’clock in the morning of 4 June 1971 in the Bay Court Hotel together with the accused Roberto Martinez and five (5) armed men who rode in a jeep and escorted the Goody-Goody truck to the hotel premises and left the hotel together at about 9:00 o’clock that morning.

Conspiracy can also be inferred from the fact that after the commission of the robbery in the U.S. naval base, the accused appellant and his co-accused, Manuel Mateo, Jr. and Roberto Martinez, fled together to the house of Fiscal Dante Filoteo, where they “holed out” until they were persuaded to surrender to the authorities in the early morning of 5 June 1971.

Besides, the alibi of the appellant is riot convincing. His claim that he was in his house at about the time the robbery was perpetrated in Sangley Point, Cavite, looking over the spare parts which were delivered to him by one Benigno Medina, appears to be an afterthought. No record of the alleged transaction was presented in court and the jeep he was supposed to assemble for one Danny Abarro could not be traced. He reasoned that Abarro who is now living abroad, had allegedly sold the jeep to one Penny Lalana who is now deceased.

The appellant’s claim that he went to the house of the chief of police to seek protection after having been told by the desk sergeant that there was a shoot-to-kill order Out for him and that he then transferred to the house of Fiscal Dante Filoteo in order to get the fiscal’s help in surrendering to the police authorities, is incredible. To begin with, the desk sergeant, one Salazar, who is now conveniently deceased, could not have told the appellant at 11:00 o’clock in the morning of 4 June 1971 of an alleged shoot-to-kill order as a result of the robbery in Sangley Point, because his co-accused Emmanuel Caganap, who implicated the appellant in the bank robbery, was investigated only at about 1:35 o’clock in the afternoon of 4 June 1971.

And, if his purpose in going to the house of Fiscal Dante Filoteo was to seek the latter’s help in order to surrender, why did he not surrender to Fiscal Filoteo earlier when they met at the house of the chief of police? Again, there was no point in going to Fiscal Filoteo in order to surrender when he was already at the police station and all he had to do was to give up to the desk sergeant. It is unfortunate that the said desk sergeant is already dead and cannot answer the appellant’s charge that he was remiss in the performance of his duty to arrest the appellant, pursuant to the shoot-to-kill order.

Moreover, the Court has held in a great number of cases that for alibi to prosper. It is not enough to prove that the accused was somewhere else when the crime was committed, but it must be also shown that it was physically impossible for him to have been at the scene of the crime at the time of its commission. 17

The appellant was in Cavite City when the robbery was committed and his then proximity to the scene of the crime does not rule the possibility that he could be at the scene of the crime at the time it was committed. In fact, the trial court found that the ‘flimsiness of the defense of alibi is exposed by the nearness of the accused to the scene of the crime. 18

The trial court found the appellant guilty of the crime of Robbery in Band with Homicide. This is not correct. In the case of People vs. Pedroso19 the Court said:

… There is no special complex crime of robbery in band with double homicide and/or serious, less serious or slight physical injuries under the present Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 373. If robbery with homicide (or with the other crimes enumerated above) is committed by a band, the indictable offense would still be denominated as “robbery with homicide” under Article 294(l), but the circumstance that it was committed by a band is not an element of the crime but is merely a generic aggravating circumstance which may be offset by mitigating circumstances. The homicides or murders and physical injuries , irrespective of their numbers, committed on the occasion or by reason of the robbery are merged in the composite crime of “robbery homicide.”… (Emphasis supplied)

Accordingly, the appellant should be found guilty of the crime of “Robbery with Homicide.” The penalty of ofreclusion perpetua imposed by the trial court is correct. But, the amount to be paid to the heirs of the slain marine officer should be increased to P30,000.00 in line with the recent decisions of the Court.

We also find that the penalty imposed upon the appellant, Enrique Concepcion, in Crim. Cases Nos. CCC-VII-844, CCC-VII-845, and CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, is not in accord with law. The penalty provided for the offense under Article 294, No. 5, of the Revised Penal Code, as amended, is prision correccional in its maximum period to prision mayor in its medium period, or which is four (4) years, two (2) months and one (1) day to ten (10) years. Applying the Indeterminate Sentence Law, the minimum period to be imposed should be within the range of the penalty next lower in degree, which is arresto mayor in its maximum period to prision correccional in its medium period, or from four (4) months and one (1) day to four (4) years and two (2) months. The minimum of the period imposed by the trial court, which is four (4) years, two (2) months and one (1) day, is obviously beyond the period provided for by law. It should be reduced accordingly.

With respect to the maximum period, there being two (2) aggravating circumstances and no mitigating circumstance, the maximum of the period, which is ten (10) years, should be imposed. The correct penalty to be imposed upon the appellant, Enrique Concepcion, in each of the three (3) aforementioned cases (CCC-VII-844, CCC-VII-845, CCC-VII-846-Cavite City) should, therefore, be imprisonment of from four (4) years and two (2) months, as minimum, to ten (10) years, as maximum.

WHEREFORE, with the modifications above-indicated, the judgment appealed from is hereby AFFIRMED. With costs.

SO ORDERED.

Paras, Sarmiento and Regalado, JJ., concur.

Melencio-Herrera (Chairman), J., is on leave.

Footnotes

1 Original Record of CCC-VII-843-Cavite City, p. 5.

2 Original Record of CCC-VII-844-Cavite City, pp. 1-2.

3 Original Record of CCC-VII-845-Cavite City, pp. 1-2.

4 Original Record of CCC-VII-846-Cavite City, pp. 1-2.

5 Original Record, p. 22.

6 Id., p. 659.

7 Id., p. 418.

8 Brief for defendant-appellant, pp. 97-100, Rollo, p. 74.

9 Rollo, p. 85; Original Record, p. 1410.

10 Brief of the appellee, pp. 5-20, Rollo, p. 86.

11 Brief for the appellee, pp. 21-24, Rollo, p. 86.

12 People vs. Carbonell, 48 Phil. 868.

13 Exhibits A, P, Q, R and S.

14 People vs. Legaspi, G.R. Nos. 55103-04, August 18, 1988 164 SCRA 481, 488, citing People vs. Garcia, 101 Phil. 616.

15 See tsn of July 12, 1971, pp. 6-27 and tsn of February 5, 1972, p. 11.

16 G.R. No. L-32529, May l2, 1978, 83 SCRA 125, 163.

17 People vs. Mercado, G.R. Nos. L-39511-13, April 28, 1980, 97 SCRA 232, 247.

18 Brief for defendant-appellant . p. 86, Rollo. p. 74.

19 G.R. No. L-32997, July 30, 1982, 115 SCRA 599, 608-609.


The Lawphil Project – Arellano Law Foundation

Naval Security Group Sangley Point, Cavite City, Luzon, Philippines

Naval Security Group Station History Dates		Updated: 	13 Jul 08
========================================================================================
Station							Opened     Closed/Disestablished
Sangley Point, Cavite City, Luzon, Philippines

Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Olongapo, 	   Jul 1930        Feb 1935
   Luzon, Philippines
   Moved to Mariveles, Los Banitos, Luzon, Philippines     Feb 1935
Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Mariveles,	01 Mar 1935  	05 Jan 1936
   Los Banitos, Bataan Province, Luzon, Philippines
   Moved to Cavite City, Luzon, Philippines		05 Jan 1936
Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Cavite,	 	05 Jan 1936        Oct 1940
   Luzon, Philippines
   DF station established Sep 1936
   Moved to Corregidor 					   Oct 1940
Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Corregidor, 	   Oct 1940        Apr 1942
   Luzon, Philippines
   Evacuated to Melbourne, Australia			   Apr 1942
Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Melbourne	   May 1942  	01 Nov 1945
   Australia, at Moorabbin

Comunications Radio Intelligence Unit, Sangley Point 	       1933        Dec 1941
   Luzon, Philippines; near the Naval Hospital at
      Canacao. (Station C)
   DF equipment installed in late 1935.
   DF station established in May 1937.
   Moved to Corregidor after 08 Dec 1941.
Occupied by the Japanese				   Jan 1942 	20 Mar 1945
Naval Air Base, Sangley Point, Philippines 		       1945      Early 1955
Naval Station Sangley Point, Philippines		 Early 1955     01 Jul 1971
   Deactivated 						01 Jul 1971	01 Sep 1971
   Turned over to the government of the Philippines	01 Sep 1971

NSG Dept, NCS Philippines, Sangley Point, Philippines	   Jun 1954 	   Jan 1958
   COMSEC Unit #703
   Moved to San Miguel, Philippines                        Jan 1958

A Brief History of Sangley Point

A Brief History of Sangley Point

The Spanish Era

The U.S. Naval Station Sangley Point was located on a peninsula jutting into Manila Bay, approximately eight miles southwest of the city of Manila.
Prior to the arrival of the Americans in 1898, the Spanish colonial government of the Philippine Islands, which had ruled the Philippines since 1571, found a useful purpose for the tiny peninsula across the bay. Ever distrustful of the Chinese merchants who called on every port from Japan to the Arabian peninsula, the Spanish passed laws restricting their entry into the capitol city of Manila. These Chinese merchants, then known as xiang-li, could, however, peddle their wares across the bay from the city on the narrow strip of land that would eventually bear their name. In addition to their role as international traders, Chinese artisan and craftsmen were employed as inexpensive labor by the Spanish shipbuilders who built ships at Sangley that were used in the galleon trade route between Manila and Acapulco, Mexico.

In 1871 the Spanish established a naval hospital, managed by the Sisters of Charity, at Cañacao near the western end of the peninsula. In addition, as the age of sail began to wane and the age of steam was ushered in, the eastern end of Sangley Point became a coaling station and support facility for the Spanish naval base located just across Cañacao Bay at the Cavite naval yard.

The U.S. Takes Possession

In 1898 diplomatic relations between the United States and Spain were strained by events related to the insurrection taking place on the Spanish controlled island of Cuba.
In anticipation of hostilities with Spain, then Assistant Secretary of the Navy Theodore Roosevelt ordered the U.S. Asiatic Squadron, under the command of Commodore George Dewey aboard the USS Olympia, to proceed to the British Crown Colony of Hong Kong. There he was to make preparations to move on the Spanish Fleet in the Philippines, believed to be anchored at Subic Bay. After war with Spain had broken out following the explosion of the USS Maine in Havana harbor, Dewey proceeded to the Philippines and arrived at Subic Bay just before sunset on April 30, 1898. However, Spanish naval authorities had determined that their position there was undefendable and had moved the fleet to Manila Bay.
Under cover of darkness, Dewey proceeded to Manila Bay, arriving just off Corregidor after 11 pm. The ships stealthily moved past the south side of the island fortress, through Boca Grande, and into Manila Bay.
Shortly after midnight they had nearly passed unnoticed when soot in the USS McCulloch’s smokestack caught fire, revealing the squadron’s position. Spanish batteries on the south shore near Punta Restinga and on El Fraile island opened fire on the shadowy ships. A few rounds were fired in response by the USS Raleigh. One shell scored a direct hit on El Fraile battery. The Spanish guns then fell silent after firing only three rounds. However, the big guns on Corregidor remained silent. Although concerned that his presence may had been revealed, Dewey proceeded slowly eastward toward Manila.
Dawn was beginning to break on the morning of May 1 as the squadron arrived at Manila. At first, however, lookouts posted high on the American ships could not locate the enemy fleet. Then, off to the right, they spotted a number of white buildings on the narrow strip of land known as Sangley Point, and beyond them a line of dark gray objects on the water. A hard turn to starboard brought the American squadron to bear on the Spanish fleet. The Spanish ships were anchored in an arc stretching eastward and southward from the mouth of Cañacao Bay near the tip of Sangley Point. As they approached, the column of American ships, with Olympia at the head of the line, followed by Baltimore, Raleigh, Petrel, Concord, and Boston, gradually turned to starboard, bringing their port guns to bear on the Spanish fleet. Dewey turned to Captain Charles V. Gridley, commanding officer of Olympia, and said, “You may fire when ready, Gridley.” At 5:41 a.m. the squadron opened fire. The Battle of Manila Bay had begun.
At last, just as the sun of May 1 rose over the hills and meadows of Luzon, the Olympia’s eight-inch guns in the forward turret burst forth at 5.000 yards range as the signal that the action should begin, she herself turning to starboard and leading the column past the enemy with port broadsides bearing. About the same time two while columns of water rushed upward in front of the flagship as if from exploded mines.
The smoke from the first discharge, as it sagged away, disclosed a long, lead-colored launch coming out from behind Sangley Point and standing rapidly toward the flagship, flying the Spanish flag. The secondary batteries of the flagship and Baltimore turned upon her a hail of shell, under which she stood on for awhile with plucky persistence, but finally fled toward Sangley Point, where she was beached and abandoned under the guns of the fort. She was afterward claimed by the owner of the marine railway at Cañacao, a Britisher, who said she was only going to market at Manila, but as this man’s Spanish sympathies and interests were strong, it seems quite probable that she had been impressed by the enemy as a torpedo-boat.
(from THE NAVAL BATTLE OF MANILA.
By LIEUTENANT JOHN M. ELLICOTT, U.S. Navy.)
The firing became incessant, the white smoke of gunfire becoming so thick that it was difficult to gauge accuracy or effectiveness. Although trapped in the narrow confines of Cañacao Bay, the Spanish fleet managed to maintain a heavy barrage of return fire.
However, most of the Spanish gunfire fell short of its mark. After making five passes in front of the enemy fleet, Dewey withdrew at 7:35 a.m. to investigate reports that he was low on ammunition. He passed the word that the men should take advantage of the break to eat breakfast. One gunner, eager to return to action, yelled out, “For God’s sake, Captain. Don’t let us stop now! To hell with breakfast!”

Just after 11:00 a.m., after determining that the report of low ammunition was in error and that his ships had suffered little or no battle damage, Dewey re-engaged the enemy. However, this time he met very little resistance. As the smoke cleared, the devastation inflicted by American guns became clearly evident. With the exception of a few gunboats, the Spanish fleet had been totally annihilated. More than 300 Spanish sailors had been killed or wounded. There were no casualties on the American side. By 12:30 p.m., the Spanish colors over the arsenal at Sangley Point were replaced by a white flag. The Battle of Manila Bay was over.

The following day the naval facilities at Cavite and Sangley Point were officially taken over by U.S. Naval Expeditionary Forces under the command of Commodore George Dewey.
Sangley Point continued to serve essentially the same function for the U.S. Navy as it had for the Spanish navy. The coaling facilities on the eastern end continued to supply the Navy with coal until ships converted to oil. At that time a tank farm was established to provide the US Pacific fleet with fuel oil.

The Cañacao Naval Hospital Reservation was established on the western end. The US Navy continued to operate the hospital started by the Spanish. In the mid-1920′s a new modern hospital was built as part of a major construction project to modernized the facility. The new hospital continued to serve the Navy, as well as the local population, until early 1942. Sadly, it was destroyed during World War II.

Three 600-foot steel antenna towers were erected in 1915 for the operation of a powerful radio communications station, named Radio Sangley. Later on, a submarine support facility was established. As naval aviation grew, a seaplane facility was established which also served as sevice facility for the Pan American China Clipper service. The Cavite U.S. Navy Yard, just across Cañacao Bay, became the major ship repair facility for the Asiatic fleet.

However, World War II and the Japanese occupation of the Philippines interrupted all US naval operations in early 1942.

World War II

The first bombing by the Japanese on December 10, 1941, heavily damaged the Cavite Navy Yard. Japanese forces occupied Cavite in January 1942. the Japanese continued to use Sangley and Cavite for basically the same purpose. They rehabilitated and expanded the facilities and used them for repair of their own craft and construction of small wooden vessels for coastal shipping of supplies.
Post-War Years

American carrier-based planes first bombed the repair facility in September 1944. The Cavite Navy Yard was again badly damaged, as were most of the hospital buildings at Cañacao.
On March 20, 1945, units of the Seventh Fleet landed on Sangley Point, chasing the Japanese out of the area. Within a month, ACORN-45 arrived and set up an advance base maintenance organization, under the command of Cmdr Donald W. Darby. They immediately began construction of an airstrip in preparation for the attack on the Japanese mainland.

The base maintenance organization was officially designated Naval Air Base (NAB), Sangley Point in 1945. Early in 1955, top echelon planners of the Navy recognized the importance of Sangley Point services and designated it as a permanent facility. Later, after the establishment of the naval air station at NAS Cubi Point at Subic Bay, the designation was changed to Naval Station (NS) Sangley Point in accordance with the treaty with the Philippine government which allowed for only one official naval air station (NAS).

The Naval Station Sangley Point was not large, encompassing an area of only 341 acres. Half of which was occupied by its most valuable asset: the 8000 foot runway and its associated air-operations facilities and air-navigational aids. The primary mission of Sangley was to provide maintenance, support, and materials for the regional operations of U.S. Seventh Fleet.
The base was the headquarters of Commander U.S. Naval Forces Philippines/ Commander In Chief Pacific Representative Philippines (COMNAVPHIL/ CINCPACREPPHIL), considered to be the most important activity supported by Naval Station Sangley Point.
It also supported two patrol squadrons, deployed on Sangley on a rotational basis to help fulfill the Mutual Defense Pact with the Philippines.
The Coast Guard Air Station and the CG Ship Nettle played a vital role in search-and-rescue operations and in the maintenance of remote long-range aid-to navigation (LORAN) stations located throughout the Philippines. The Fleet Weather Facility was tasked with furnishing weather information to ships and aircraft operating in the Western Pacific and East China Sea areas.

The Naval Station Sangley Point also provided support for one Fleet Air Wing detachment, a Naval Communications Center, Marine Barracks, a Recruiting Detachment, and Navy Exchange and Commissary Stores.

Closure

Early in December 1970, it was officially announced that U.S. Naval Station Sangley Point would be closed. On July 1, 1971, Sangley Point changed status from active to inactive in preparation for the turnover of the facility to the government of the Philippines. The Sangley Point Closure Detail was activated under the command of an Officer-In-Charge, Capt. Waldo Atkins, with a 95-man, 7-officer contingent.
In the extremely compressed 60-day period of deactivation, more than 350 items of automotive and construction equipment were transferred; over 400 industrial buildings and government quarters were stripped of furnishings; installed equipment was disconnected and readied for shipment, and all buildings were secured.

(Click on an area of the map for a close-up of that area.)

A total of 2,500 tons and 1,500,000 cubic feet of material assets were identified, packed and shipped by sea and land to various other U.S. military bases. Much of this transfer was accomplished at night and on weekends due to severely restricted barge and trucking schedules.
Approximately 300,000 pounds of materials and supplies were prepared for turnover to the government of the Philippines, including 375 buildings, 77 structures and 60 utilities systems and improvements. In connection with the relocation of equipment and materials to other bases, 49 stilt housing units were relocated to Subic Bay by a detachment of SEABEES. On-the-job-training sessions were conducted for Philippine naval personnel to ensure the safe and proper operation of all base industrial facilities.
Operating under the most austere conditions of manpower, material and transportation facilities, and handicapped by the adverse effects of the rainy season, and two minor typhoons which passed near the base, personnel of the closure detail extended their work day and carried on during the weekends in order to meet the rigid and inflexible schedule.
The End Of An Era

On September 1, 1971, the base was officially turned over to the government of the Philippines, thus ending 73 historic years as a U.S. Naval facility. It is currently used as a facility of the Armed Forces of the Philippines.
by Loren Stiegelmar
©2001